Selected Reviews
& Notes
For Selected Reviews & Notes
in
Hebrew
"There
is no
other book quite like this one, it really is singular and
worthy of your close attention..."
**
Michael W. Mehaffy / URBAN
DESIGN International
(2007) 12, Palgrave Macmillan Journal
In her
introductory biographical note, architect Nili Portugali
describes her
early and unsatisfactory encounter with the quantitative methodologies
of late 1960s' architecture and planning…. hers is not a
work of philosophy, but a case study of a particular approach to
architecture, and the real aim is to present the work and discuss its
evolution. She does this in great detail. Indeed, next to the verbiage
of many architectural monographs, hers is clear enough…..
Drawing on analogies to Shaker buildings, Buddhist philosophy and other
sources, she describes the fundamental difference between collections
and assemblies of fragmented parts, and the process of
differentiation….This notion of differentiating from an
existing condition – of transforming an existing whole
– is key to Portugali's design method… Portugali
lays out a remarkably diverse set of projects: public buildings,
mixed-use commercial projects, private houses….. It does not
refer to any particular style, nor does it include the mix of stylistic
elements that architectural critics love to hate – the
dreaded 'pastiche'….And yet, neither is it obsessed with
invention and constant newness.
There is an
ordinariness about it, a
familiarity, and yet a sense of uniqueness, striking beauty and dignity
too.
It does not
seem too concerned with being 'of its time', date-stamped
as fashionably current….. Portugali notes that she does not
try to reconstruct the past, nor does she try to avoid re-creating it.
Rather, she simply follows the patterns that are appropriate for a site
and context, which are often the same ones that have been appropriate
in the past, and are likely to be appropriate in the future.
…… This is Portugali's… humanist
design philosophy: insistent that technology, of whatever time and
place, must above all be the servant of human well-being….
There is in this sense a universality to Portugali's work that is in
one sense unremarkable and in another, in the context of so much
contemporary architecture, radical and revolutionary….
Portugali's quiet
revolution may be the one that passes the ultimate
test of time.
**
John Lobell / Journal of
Architectural
Education (JAE), Volume 62:2, 2008, Wiley / Blackwell
"She is an
Architect more than a theorist. This is an important distinction
because what she is
presenting in the book is a codified methodology
derived from her architectural practice. Portugali, like
Alexander believes in universals
in the human psyche because, as she writes, ‘‘there
is
an ultimate truth common to us all as human
beings”……
If Portugali’s holistic-phenomenological approach to
architecture is not new, it is nonetheless refreshing
and her book will be of great value to anyone who
believes that what ever else buildings should mean or
be or do, they should at the very least satisfy
us as
human."
**
Gilad Duvshani / Books Supplement, Ha'aretz
December 13, 2006
"It is not
every day that a book is published which describes the world view of an
Israeli architect with a fascinating body of work and a structured
thesis about how architecture should be practiced here, Such is Nili
Portugali’s book..."
**
'Arquitectura' magazine, 1.3.2007
The
Art of
Creation and the Spirit of Place (A Arte da
Criação e o Espírito do Lugar), o
livro em que Nili Portugali desenvolve, com o apoio de quase 600
ilustrações, a sua
concepção de arquitectura holística,
foi publicado pela editora Axel-Menges, de Estugarda e Londres, e
declarado 'Livro da Semana' na categoria de livros de arquitectura,
pela Associação Britânica de
Arquitectos.
**
**
Notes
**
Clive Anderton, The Deputy
Private secretary
TRH The Prince of Wales and the Duchess of Cornwall
Her
Royal
Highness was deeply touched that you thought of
him….looks forward very much to dipping in to your
fascinating book…
**
Prof. Michael Turner, Architect
Chairman of UNESCO World Heritage, Israel office
Department of Architecture, Bezalel Academy of Arts and Design,
Jerusalem
‘Ms
Portugali has developed the holistic
approach to
architecture and design. The subject matter is becoming increasingly
important with the highlighting of a more humanistic approach to
architecture and the need to translate the issues of sustainability and
environment in the language of design. I feel that the
….could fill a need between the simple architectural
monologue and the rather obscure architectural
theories…… The
author has had much experience in
research and teaching over the years and has an active architectural
practice where she puts her ideas into practice…. She has
been recognized by the professional community with a number of prizes
and awards, thus recognizing her very special approach to architecture.
I believe that the book could have an appeal for an intelligent
lay-public’
**
Prof. Zeev Druckman, Architect
Head of the Department of Architecture, Bezalel Academy of Arts
& Design, Jerusalem in
1990-2002
‘I
see the utmost importance in Nili
Portugali’s
book where she discusses a line of thought which presents
a holistic,
infinite and timeless architecture, as against other books presenting
finite and one – time works of architecture. All this makes
the book unique and important to Architects, students, academics and
all those thinkers who see the world as a system of relationships on
any level….’
**
Dr. Artemis Anninou, Architect
Co-Author with Christopher Alexander / A New Theory of Urban
Design/Oxford University
Press, 1987
A member of The Elliniki Technodomiki
/ Aktor /TEB Group, Greece
‘All
her buildings portray a humanistic
approach to design
and construction; people have priority in all her projects; the
importance of every detail, every material, and every color is obvious
when you see the whole and how they are combined together. And all she
did has come out of the
deep drive to improve buildings and
architecture and the life of people who use them. The book
exemplifies
her personality and the talents…. The
uniqueness of this book, in relation to other architectural books,
relies to the fact that there has no book written about the
interrelation between the theoretical ideas discussed in the
internationally scientific discourse and its implementation or
interpretation in the Architecture within context of Israel, the
Mediterranean & the middle east region. And thus being of
international interest…’
**
Jean Renoux
Ecologreen , Art & Architectural Tours & Seminars
"Your book would be another
voice, another way to tell the profession that we need at some point
soon to look at architecture in a much more holistic way, putting back
some emotion into it, connecting architecture to the earth and not
creating totally artificial surroundings that disconnect us from our
origins, from nature."
**
Scott Doddington, Manager, Cody's
Bookshop, San Francisco
"In reading about your book, I
must say that I'm fascinated by and in
completeWith your design philosophy. I think that many others in our
agreement
community will also respond to this book as well..."
**
Eva Marie Mercurio, Rhode Island
School of Design
"I'm currently an older
student of architecture in Rhode Island, USA.
I came across your book. I just love it, your projects, and the thought
process behind the projects!! Although I live many miles from you,
thank you for your wonderful contributions to society, the
architectural profession and the spirit of life!"
**
Prof. Nikos Salingaros,
Department
of mathematics, University of Texas, San Antonio
Practicing Urbanist and Architectural Theorist
"I am reading your new book,
which our library just got. Congratulations, it is a very nice book,
and I love your buildings. I hope you can reach a wide audience this
way..."
**
Prof. John Habraken,
Architect, educator, theorist, head of the Department of Architecture,
MIT, Cambridge, MA in 1975-1981
"It is a real handsome
contribution to my
library. But most importantly, browsing it, gave a sense of relief to
read about architecture in that humane and sensitive way so different
from the usual posturing. And see projects that display the same
sensible attitude. Buildings that are so much at ease with themselves
and their surroundings, and so attentively developed and detailed. You
set a much needed role model.
"
**
|
|